Insert sound of cartoon character doing a double take.

Is it Jessica, or is it Ashlee?

Is it Casper, or is it Gwenyth?

Is it Castaway, or is it Matthew? (And OH MY GOD. Here I just thought his abs were big!)

(Oh COME ON, it had to be said.)

Is it Skeletor, or is it Katie?

And finally, I never thought I would say this, but I would KILL to be Jamie Lee Curtis for a day...